With part one of the movie of the iconic Latin American
revolutionary currently doing the rounds in the quality cinemas,
and part two out shortly, Liz Walker reviews Steven
Soderberghs long awaited Che part 1.
![]() |
Im glad I didnt see the
poster advertising this film before I went into the
cinema because I might have turned on my heel and walked
out. According to the blurb on the poster this was
A Great Hollywood War Movie a farcical
statement which thankfully turned out to contravene the
Trade Description Act. |
| Director Steven Soderbergh, who is
perhaps better known for the Oceans Eleven movies
and the remake of Solaris, has created a film in two
parts (part two will be on release shortly) which was
timed to coincide with the fiftieth anniversary in
January of the revolutionary overthrow of the Cuban
dictator Batista. The film
starts with a meeting between Ernesto Che
Guevara (played by Benicio del Toro) and Fidel Castro
(Demian Bichir) in 1955 in Mexico City and follows the
small invasion party as it gradually attracts more
followers who establish a base in the Sierra Maestra in
Cuba to wage a guerrilla war of liberation against the
oppressive and corrupt Batista regime. We are
shown Che battling with his chronic asthma as he and his
comrades slog their way through the Cuban hinterland
fighting their way towards Havana in 1959. He
instils discipline and order on the group not only in
terms of survival and weapons skills, but also in
encouraging all those who join to learn to read, saying
that if you cant read you cant tell when you
are being deceived. At one point he tells a weary comrade
who has just come off watch and wants to lie down to get
his maths book and study. This is obviously a
not-so-veiled reference to the educational achievements
of the Cuban revolution moving from a situation
where a majority of poor peasants and workers were
illiterate to having significantly higher literacy rates
than the revolutions greatest enemy the USA. Interspersed
with the scenes in Cuba which are shot in colour are
flash forwards to Ches time in the United States
and his famous speech at the UN in 1964, which is grainy
documentary style black and white. The monochrome
episodes are very skilfully done and beautifully evoke a
real feeling of time and place. But
for me the best decision Soderbergh made was to shoot the
film mainly in Spanish using Spanish speaking actors (who
are uniformly excellent), with subtitles for the English
speaking audience, which engenders a real feeling of
authenticity and closeness to the events. If he had
copped out and gone for an English speaking movie with
big name Holywood actors the movie would surely have been
a disastrous mockery. Towards
the end of the film the revolutionaries are on their way
to Havana. Che forbids the men to indulge in looting, and
then a wonderful flashback to Mexico City in 1955 brings
the film full circle, giving it a graceful and satisfying
completeness, even though this is only part one. This
wonderful film is an amazing adventure story about trying
to create a new society, and this is summed up for me by
one small scene near the end when a reporter asks Che if
he is happy the revolution is over. |
| He replies The war is
over, the revolution is just beginning. |
![]() |