Willie
and Derek Duncan recall the
UKs worst football disaster 20 years on from the horrific
events of Hillsborough, and outline a fight for justice and truth
that goes on to this day.
Hillsborough.
The very name is enough to chill the blood of those who remember
the tragic events that unfolded in the now infamous sporting
arena. It was, and still is, the worst stadium related disaster
in the history of British football. On April 15th, 1989, fans of
Nottingham Forest and Liverpool descended on Sheffield
anticipating what was to be an exciting and entertaining match
between two of the top sides in the country. Tragically, the day
would live long in the memory for all the wrong reasons.
At
3.06, just 6 minutes after the scheduled kick-off time, the match
was abandoned. However, for 96 fans, all supporters of Liverpool,
the abandonment was simply too late. Their deaths, the result of
a human crush, sent shockwaves that were felt around the world
and felt by those both inside and outside of football. The
disaster changed the face of modern football stadia and the
Taylor Report, which I will return to later, recommended the
implementation of all-seater football stadiums in the UK and the
removal of barriers at the front of the stands.
Before
looking in more depth at the Taylor Report, it is important to
examine what happened on the day itself and how these events
culminated in 96 tragic deaths. As is always the case in modern
football, Hillsborough Stadium employed a segregation policy and
Liverpool fans were allocated the Leppings Lane end. At around
2.30pm, a problem was beginning to develop outside of the
stadium. Thousands of Liverpool fans, congregated outside of the
stadium all desperate to get into the stadium and take their
place in the stadium ahead of the kick-off. Quickly, a bottleneck
developed as more and more fans arrived and, to make matters
worse, those who, for a number of reasons, were refused entry
were unable to leave the area due to the crowds.
In
an attempt to alleviate the problem, the police opened a side
gate - which was not intended to be used as an entrance - and
this led to supporters rushing through the gate into the stadium.
The police believed that by doing this, the possibility of a
crush outside the stadium had been averted and that the right
decision had been taken. Sadly, in truth, the problem was about
to get much, much worse.
Thousands
of fans rushed through the side gate; they made their way into 2
central sections of the Leppings Lane end which, unbeknown to the
fans, were already overcrowded. At the front of the terracing,
fans were crushed against the fencing designed to prevent pitch
invasions. Eventually, as fans began to climb the fences and make
their way onto the pitch, the match referee, on the advice of
police - who initially appeared to believe that a pitch invasion
was taking place - abandoned the match. Some fans managed to
force open a small gate in the fencing, others were pulled to
safety by fans in the West Stand - directly above the Leppings
Lane terracing. As chaos ensued, the fencing broke under the
sheer force of the fans pushed against it.
As
fans spilled onto the pitch, uninjured fans did what they could
to help. At this time, police formed a cordon which was designed
to prevent Liverpool fans from reaching the Nottingham Forest end
of the stadium and, indeed, some fans who tried to break the
cordon to lead injured fans to safety were forcibly turned back.
Incredibly, by this time, 44 ambulances had reached Hillsborough
but all but one was turned away by police.
| In the days and months that followed, the
inquests and inquiries took place. However, memorably and
despicably, the Sun Newspaper - typically - refused to
allow the facts of the day get in the way of a good
story. Just 4 days after the tragedy, the paper ran what
amounted to a shameful smear campaign which accused
Liverpool fans of picking the pockets of the dead,
abusing and urinating on police officers who were helping
victims and even went as far as to suggest that a dead
female fan had been "abused". In the fine
traditions of the Sun, all of these allegations were
attributed to an "unnamed source". To this day,
the Sun newspaper is widely boycotted in Liverpool and it
is estimated that circulation in the city is currently
around 12,000 copies per day - a staggering 200,000 fewer
than prior to the disaster. The newspaper finally issued
an apology in July 2004 but for many in Liverpool; it was
regarded as too little, too late - the Liverpool Echo
dismissing the apology as "shabby". |
![]() |
The
Taylor Report and other inquests into the Hillsborough disaster
have also left a bad taste in the mouth of the relatives of
victims. The coroner, Dr Stefan Popper, has claimed that all
victims were dead, or at least, brain dead by 3.15pm - just 9
minutes after the abandonment of the match and, so, the main
inquest was limited to events before 3.15 - this angered many of
the relatives.
Furthermore,
the Taylor Inquiry found that the failure of the police to
control the crowds was the main cause of the tragedy. It was
indicated that the tragedy would have been avoidable had the
kick-off been delayed. The suggestion by some in South Yorkshire
Police that the drunkenness of Liverpool fans was a mitigating
factor and the further claim that the late gathering of fans
outside the stadium was an attempt to gain entry to the stadium
without a ticket was dismissed by Taylor.
Some
fans have brought a private prosecution against the officer in
charge on the day, Chief Superintendent David Duckenfield, on the
basis that he lied when telling senior FA officials that
Liverpool fans had forced the gate open - a claim that he was
forced to admit to. The prosecution was dismissed when
Duckenfield's doctor said that his client was medically unfit to
face prosecution.
Every
year, a memorial service is held at Anfield Stadium - home of
Liverpool FC. However, 20 years on, the relatives of the families
are angry that nobody has been held account for the tragic events
which took place on April 15th 1989. For the families, in the
form of campaign group the Hillsborough Justice Campaign, the
fight goes on for justice.
As
of yet, the answers that they seek are not forthcoming. However,
the memory of the Hillsborough tragedy should, we can only hope,
ensure that the scenes witnessed on that day are never seen
again.